{- (c) The University of Glasgow 2006 (c) The GRASP/AQUA Project, Glasgow University, 1992-1998 Handles @deriving@ clauses on @data@ declarations. -} {-# LANGUAGE CPP #-} {-# LANGUAGE MultiWayIf #-} {-# LANGUAGE TypeFamilies #-} module TcDeriv ( tcDeriving, DerivInfo(..) ) where #include "HsVersions.h" import GhcPrelude import GHC.Hs import DynFlags import TcRnMonad import FamInst import TcOrigin import Predicate import TcDerivInfer import TcDerivUtils import TcValidity( allDistinctTyVars ) import TcClassDcl( instDeclCtxt3, tcATDefault ) import TcEnv import TcGenDeriv -- Deriv stuff import TcValidity( checkValidInstHead ) import InstEnv import Inst import FamInstEnv import TcHsType import TyCoRep import TyCoPpr ( pprTyVars ) import RnNames( extendGlobalRdrEnvRn ) import RnBinds import RnEnv import RnUtils ( bindLocalNamesFV ) import RnSource ( addTcgDUs ) import Avail import Unify( tcUnifyTy ) import Class import Type import ErrUtils import DataCon import Maybes import RdrName import Name import NameSet import TyCon import TcType import Var import VarEnv import VarSet import PrelNames import SrcLoc import Util import Outputable import FastString import Bag import FV (fvVarList, unionFV, mkFVs) import qualified GHC.LanguageExtensions as LangExt import Control.Monad import Control.Monad.Trans.Class import Control.Monad.Trans.Reader import Data.List (partition, find) {- ************************************************************************ * * Overview * * ************************************************************************ Overall plan ~~~~~~~~~~~~ 1. Convert the decls (i.e. data/newtype deriving clauses, plus standalone deriving) to [EarlyDerivSpec] 2. Infer the missing contexts for the InferTheta's 3. Add the derived bindings, generating InstInfos -} data EarlyDerivSpec = InferTheta (DerivSpec [ThetaOrigin]) | GivenTheta (DerivSpec ThetaType) -- InferTheta ds => the context for the instance should be inferred -- In this case ds_theta is the list of all the sets of -- constraints needed, such as (Eq [a], Eq a), together with a -- suitable CtLoc to get good error messages. -- The inference process is to reduce this to a -- simpler form (e.g. Eq a) -- -- GivenTheta ds => the exact context for the instance is supplied -- by the programmer; it is ds_theta -- See Note [Inferring the instance context] in TcDerivInfer splitEarlyDerivSpec :: [EarlyDerivSpec] -> ([DerivSpec [ThetaOrigin]], [DerivSpec ThetaType]) splitEarlyDerivSpec [] = ([],[]) splitEarlyDerivSpec (InferTheta spec : specs) = case splitEarlyDerivSpec specs of (is, gs) -> (spec : is, gs) splitEarlyDerivSpec (GivenTheta spec : specs) = case splitEarlyDerivSpec specs of (is, gs) -> (is, spec : gs) instance Outputable EarlyDerivSpec where ppr (InferTheta spec) = ppr spec <+> text "(Infer)" ppr (GivenTheta spec) = ppr spec <+> text "(Given)" {- Note [Data decl contexts] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Consider data (RealFloat a) => Complex a = !a :+ !a deriving( Read ) We will need an instance decl like: instance (Read a, RealFloat a) => Read (Complex a) where ... The RealFloat in the context is because the read method for Complex is bound to construct a Complex, and doing that requires that the argument type is in RealFloat. But this ain't true for Show, Eq, Ord, etc, since they don't construct a Complex; they only take them apart. Our approach: identify the offending classes, and add the data type context to the instance decl. The "offending classes" are Read, Enum? FURTHER NOTE ADDED March 2002. In fact, Haskell98 now requires that pattern matching against a constructor from a data type with a context gives rise to the constraints for that context -- or at least the thinned version. So now all classes are "offending". Note [Newtype deriving] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Consider this: class C a b instance C [a] Char newtype T = T Char deriving( C [a] ) Notice the free 'a' in the deriving. We have to fill this out to newtype T = T Char deriving( forall a. C [a] ) And then translate it to: instance C [a] Char => C [a] T where ... Note [Unused constructors and deriving clauses] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ See #3221. Consider data T = T1 | T2 deriving( Show ) Are T1 and T2 unused? Well, no: the deriving clause expands to mention both of them. So we gather defs/uses from deriving just like anything else. -} -- | Stuff needed to process a datatype's `deriving` clauses data DerivInfo = DerivInfo { di_rep_tc :: TyCon -- ^ The data tycon for normal datatypes, -- or the *representation* tycon for data families , di_scoped_tvs :: ![(Name,TyVar)] -- ^ Variables that scope over the deriving clause. , di_clauses :: [LHsDerivingClause GhcRn] , di_ctxt :: SDoc -- ^ error context } {- ************************************************************************ * * \subsection[TcDeriv-driver]{Top-level function for \tr{derivings}} * * ************************************************************************ -} tcDeriving :: [DerivInfo] -- All `deriving` clauses -> [LDerivDecl GhcRn] -- All stand-alone deriving declarations -> TcM (TcGblEnv, Bag (InstInfo GhcRn), HsValBinds GhcRn) tcDeriving deriv_infos deriv_decls = recoverM (do { g <- getGblEnv ; return (g, emptyBag, emptyValBindsOut)}) $ do { -- Fish the "deriving"-related information out of the TcEnv -- And make the necessary "equations". early_specs <- makeDerivSpecs deriv_infos deriv_decls ; traceTc "tcDeriving" (ppr early_specs) ; let (infer_specs, given_specs) = splitEarlyDerivSpec early_specs ; insts1 <- mapM genInst given_specs ; insts2 <- mapM genInst infer_specs ; dflags <- getDynFlags ; let (_, deriv_stuff, fvs) = unzip3 (insts1 ++ insts2) ; loc <- getSrcSpanM ; let (binds, famInsts) = genAuxBinds dflags loc (unionManyBags deriv_stuff) ; let mk_inst_infos1 = map fstOf3 insts1 ; inst_infos1 <- apply_inst_infos mk_inst_infos1 given_specs -- We must put all the derived type family instances (from both -- infer_specs and given_specs) in the local instance environment -- before proceeding, or else simplifyInstanceContexts might -- get stuck if it has to reason about any of those family instances. -- See Note [Staging of tcDeriving] ; tcExtendLocalFamInstEnv (bagToList famInsts) $ -- NB: only call tcExtendLocalFamInstEnv once, as it performs -- validity checking for all of the family instances you give it. -- If the family instances have errors, calling it twice will result -- in duplicate error messages! do { -- the stand-alone derived instances (@inst_infos1@) are used when -- inferring the contexts for "deriving" clauses' instances -- (@infer_specs@) ; final_specs <- extendLocalInstEnv (map iSpec inst_infos1) $ simplifyInstanceContexts infer_specs ; let mk_inst_infos2 = map fstOf3 insts2 ; inst_infos2 <- apply_inst_infos mk_inst_infos2 final_specs ; let inst_infos = inst_infos1 ++ inst_infos2 ; (inst_info, rn_binds, rn_dus) <- renameDeriv inst_infos binds ; unless (isEmptyBag inst_info) $ liftIO (dumpIfSet_dyn dflags Opt_D_dump_deriv "Derived instances" (ddump_deriving inst_info rn_binds famInsts)) ; gbl_env <- tcExtendLocalInstEnv (map iSpec (bagToList inst_info)) getGblEnv ; let all_dus = rn_dus `plusDU` usesOnly (NameSet.mkFVs $ concat fvs) ; return (addTcgDUs gbl_env all_dus, inst_info, rn_binds) } } where ddump_deriving :: Bag (InstInfo GhcRn) -> HsValBinds GhcRn -> Bag FamInst -- ^ Rep type family instances -> SDoc ddump_deriving inst_infos extra_binds repFamInsts = hang (text "Derived class instances:") 2 (vcat (map (\i -> pprInstInfoDetails i $$ text "") (bagToList inst_infos)) $$ ppr extra_binds) $$ hangP "Derived type family instances:" (vcat (map pprRepTy (bagToList repFamInsts))) hangP s x = text "" $$ hang (ptext (sLit s)) 2 x -- Apply the suspended computations given by genInst calls. -- See Note [Staging of tcDeriving] apply_inst_infos :: [ThetaType -> TcM (InstInfo GhcPs)] -> [DerivSpec ThetaType] -> TcM [InstInfo GhcPs] apply_inst_infos = zipWithM (\f ds -> f (ds_theta ds)) -- Prints the representable type family instance pprRepTy :: FamInst -> SDoc pprRepTy fi@(FamInst { fi_tys = lhs }) = text "type" <+> ppr (mkTyConApp (famInstTyCon fi) lhs) <+> equals <+> ppr rhs where rhs = famInstRHS fi renameDeriv :: [InstInfo GhcPs] -> Bag (LHsBind GhcPs, LSig GhcPs) -> TcM (Bag (InstInfo GhcRn), HsValBinds GhcRn, DefUses) renameDeriv inst_infos bagBinds = discardWarnings $ -- Discard warnings about unused bindings etc setXOptM LangExt.EmptyCase $ -- Derived decls (for empty types) can have -- case x of {} setXOptM LangExt.ScopedTypeVariables $ setXOptM LangExt.KindSignatures $ -- Derived decls (for newtype-deriving) can use ScopedTypeVariables & -- KindSignatures setXOptM LangExt.TypeApplications $ -- GND/DerivingVia uses TypeApplications in generated code -- (See Note [Newtype-deriving instances] in TcGenDeriv) unsetXOptM LangExt.RebindableSyntax $ -- See Note [Avoid RebindableSyntax when deriving] setXOptM LangExt.TemplateHaskellQuotes $ -- DeriveLift makes uses of quotes do { -- Bring the extra deriving stuff into scope -- before renaming the instances themselves ; traceTc "rnd" (vcat (map (\i -> pprInstInfoDetails i $$ text "") inst_infos)) ; (aux_binds, aux_sigs) <- mapAndUnzipBagM return bagBinds ; let aux_val_binds = ValBinds noExtField aux_binds (bagToList aux_sigs) ; rn_aux_lhs <- rnTopBindsLHS emptyFsEnv aux_val_binds ; let bndrs = collectHsValBinders rn_aux_lhs ; envs <- extendGlobalRdrEnvRn (map avail bndrs) emptyFsEnv ; ; setEnvs envs $ do { (rn_aux, dus_aux) <- rnValBindsRHS (TopSigCtxt (mkNameSet bndrs)) rn_aux_lhs ; (rn_inst_infos, fvs_insts) <- mapAndUnzipM rn_inst_info inst_infos ; return (listToBag rn_inst_infos, rn_aux, dus_aux `plusDU` usesOnly (plusFVs fvs_insts)) } } where rn_inst_info :: InstInfo GhcPs -> TcM (InstInfo GhcRn, FreeVars) rn_inst_info inst_info@(InstInfo { iSpec = inst , iBinds = InstBindings { ib_binds = binds , ib_tyvars = tyvars , ib_pragmas = sigs , ib_extensions = exts -- Only for type-checking , ib_derived = sa } }) = ASSERT( null sigs ) bindLocalNamesFV tyvars $ do { (rn_binds,_, fvs) <- rnMethodBinds False (is_cls_nm inst) [] binds [] ; let binds' = InstBindings { ib_binds = rn_binds , ib_tyvars = tyvars , ib_pragmas = [] , ib_extensions = exts , ib_derived = sa } ; return (inst_info { iBinds = binds' }, fvs) } {- Note [Staging of tcDeriving] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Here's a tricky corner case for deriving (adapted from #2721): class C a where type T a foo :: a -> T a instance C Int where type T Int = Int foo = id newtype N = N Int deriving C This will produce an instance something like this: instance C N where type T N = T Int foo = coerce (foo :: Int -> T Int) :: N -> T N We must be careful in order to typecheck this code. When determining the context for the instance (in simplifyInstanceContexts), we need to determine that T N and T Int have the same representation, but to do that, the T N instance must be in the local family instance environment. Otherwise, GHC would be unable to conclude that T Int is representationally equivalent to T Int, and simplifyInstanceContexts would get stuck. Previously, tcDeriving would defer adding any derived type family instances to the instance environment until the very end, which meant that simplifyInstanceContexts would get called without all the type family instances it needed in the environment in order to properly simplify instance like the C N instance above. To avoid this scenario, we carefully structure the order of events in tcDeriving. We first call genInst on the standalone derived instance specs and the instance specs obtained from deriving clauses. Note that the return type of genInst is a triple: TcM (ThetaType -> TcM (InstInfo RdrName), BagDerivStuff, Maybe Name) The type family instances are in the BagDerivStuff. The first field of the triple is a suspended computation which, given an instance context, produces the rest of the instance. The fact that it is suspended is important, because right now, we don't have ThetaTypes for the instances that use deriving clauses (only the standalone-derived ones). Now we can can collect the type family instances and extend the local instance environment. At this point, it is safe to run simplifyInstanceContexts on the deriving-clause instance specs, which gives us the ThetaTypes for the deriving-clause instances. Now we can feed all the ThetaTypes to the suspended computations and obtain our InstInfos, at which point tcDeriving is done. An alternative design would be to split up genInst so that the family instances are generated separately from the InstInfos. But this would require carving up a lot of the GHC deriving internals to accommodate the change. On the other hand, we can keep all of the InstInfo and type family instance logic together in genInst simply by converting genInst to continuation-returning style, so we opt for that route. Note [Why we don't pass rep_tc into deriveTyData] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Down in the bowels of mk_deriv_inst_tys_maybe, we need to convert the fam_tc back into the rep_tc by means of a lookup. And yet we have the rep_tc right here! Why look it up again? Answer: it's just easier this way. We drop some number of arguments from the end of the datatype definition in deriveTyData. The arguments are dropped from the fam_tc. This action may drop a *different* number of arguments passed to the rep_tc, depending on how many free variables, etc., the dropped patterns have. Also, this technique carries over the kind substitution from deriveTyData nicely. Note [Avoid RebindableSyntax when deriving] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ The RebindableSyntax extension interacts awkwardly with the derivation of any stock class whose methods require the use of string literals. The Show class is a simple example (see #12688): {-# LANGUAGE RebindableSyntax, OverloadedStrings #-} newtype Text = Text String fromString :: String -> Text fromString = Text data Foo = Foo deriving Show This will generate code to the effect of: instance Show Foo where showsPrec _ Foo = showString "Foo" But because RebindableSyntax and OverloadedStrings are enabled, the "Foo" string literal is now of type Text, not String, which showString doesn't accept! This causes the generated Show instance to fail to typecheck. To avoid this kind of scenario, we simply turn off RebindableSyntax entirely in derived code. ************************************************************************ * * From HsSyn to DerivSpec * * ************************************************************************ @makeDerivSpecs@ fishes around to find the info about needed derived instances. -} makeDerivSpecs :: [DerivInfo] -> [LDerivDecl GhcRn] -> TcM [EarlyDerivSpec] makeDerivSpecs deriv_infos deriv_decls = do { eqns1 <- sequenceA [ deriveClause rep_tc scoped_tvs dcs preds err_ctxt | DerivInfo { di_rep_tc = rep_tc , di_scoped_tvs = scoped_tvs , di_clauses = clauses , di_ctxt = err_ctxt } <- deriv_infos , L _ (HsDerivingClause { deriv_clause_strategy = dcs , deriv_clause_tys = L _ preds }) <- clauses ] ; eqns2 <- mapM (recoverM (pure Nothing) . deriveStandalone) deriv_decls ; return $ concat eqns1 ++ catMaybes eqns2 } ------------------------------------------------------------------ -- | Process the derived classes in a single @deriving@ clause. deriveClause :: TyCon -> [(Name, TcTyVar)] -- Scoped type variables taken from tcTyConScopedTyVars -- See Note [Scoped tyvars in a TcTyCon] in types/TyCon -> Maybe (LDerivStrategy GhcRn) -> [LHsSigType GhcRn] -> SDoc -> TcM [EarlyDerivSpec] deriveClause rep_tc scoped_tvs mb_lderiv_strat deriv_preds err_ctxt = addErrCtxt err_ctxt $ do traceTc "deriveClause" $ vcat [ text "tvs" <+> ppr tvs , text "scoped_tvs" <+> ppr scoped_tvs , text "tc" <+> ppr tc , text "tys" <+> ppr tys , text "mb_lderiv_strat" <+> ppr mb_lderiv_strat ] tcExtendNameTyVarEnv scoped_tvs $ do (mb_lderiv_strat', via_tvs) <- tcDerivStrategy mb_lderiv_strat tcExtendTyVarEnv via_tvs $ -- Moreover, when using DerivingVia one can bind type variables in -- the `via` type as well, so these type variables must also be -- brought into scope. mapMaybeM (derivePred tc tys mb_lderiv_strat' via_tvs) deriv_preds -- After typechecking the `via` type once, we then typecheck all -- of the classes associated with that `via` type in the -- `deriving` clause. -- See also Note [Don't typecheck too much in DerivingVia]. where tvs = tyConTyVars rep_tc (tc, tys) = case tyConFamInstSig_maybe rep_tc of -- data family: Just (fam_tc, pats, _) -> (fam_tc, pats) -- NB: deriveTyData wants the *user-specified* -- name. See Note [Why we don't pass rep_tc into deriveTyData] _ -> (rep_tc, mkTyVarTys tvs) -- datatype -- | Process a single predicate in a @deriving@ clause. -- -- This returns a 'Maybe' because the user might try to derive 'Typeable', -- which is a no-op nowadays. derivePred :: TyCon -> [Type] -> Maybe (LDerivStrategy GhcTc) -> [TyVar] -> LHsSigType GhcRn -> TcM (Maybe EarlyDerivSpec) derivePred tc tys mb_lderiv_strat via_tvs deriv_pred = -- We carefully set up uses of recoverM to minimize error message -- cascades. See Note [Recovering from failures in deriving clauses]. recoverM (pure Nothing) $ setSrcSpan (getLoc (hsSigType deriv_pred)) $ do traceTc "derivePred" $ vcat [ text "tc" <+> ppr tc , text "tys" <+> ppr tys , text "deriv_pred" <+> ppr deriv_pred , text "mb_lderiv_strat" <+> ppr mb_lderiv_strat , text "via_tvs" <+> ppr via_tvs ] (cls_tvs, cls, cls_tys, cls_arg_kinds) <- tcHsDeriv deriv_pred when (cls_arg_kinds `lengthIsNot` 1) $ failWithTc (nonUnaryErr deriv_pred) let [cls_arg_kind] = cls_arg_kinds mb_deriv_strat = fmap unLoc mb_lderiv_strat if (className cls == typeableClassName) then do warnUselessTypeable return Nothing else let deriv_tvs = via_tvs ++ cls_tvs in Just <$> deriveTyData tc tys mb_deriv_strat deriv_tvs cls cls_tys cls_arg_kind {- Note [Don't typecheck too much in DerivingVia] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Consider the following example: data D = ... deriving (A1 t, ..., A20 t) via T t GHC used to be engineered such that it would typecheck the `deriving` clause like so: 1. Take the first class in the clause (`A1`). 2. Typecheck the `via` type (`T t`) and bring its bound type variables into scope (`t`). 3. Typecheck the class (`A1`). 4. Move on to the next class (`A2`) and repeat the process until all classes have been typechecked. This algorithm gets the job done most of the time, but it has two notable flaws. One flaw is that it is wasteful: it requires that `T t` be typechecked 20 different times, once for each class in the `deriving` clause. This is unnecessary because we only need to typecheck `T t` once in order to get access to its bound type variable. The other issue with this algorithm arises when there are no classes in the `deriving` clause, like in the following example: data D2 = ... deriving () via Maybe Maybe Because there are no classes, the algorithm above will simply do nothing. As a consequence, GHC will completely miss the fact that `Maybe Maybe` is ill-kinded nonsense (#16923). To address both of these problems, GHC now uses this algorithm instead: 1. Typecheck the `via` type and bring its boudn type variables into scope. 2. Take the first class in the `deriving` clause. 3. Typecheck the class. 4. Move on to the next class and repeat the process until all classes have been typechecked. This algorithm ensures that the `via` type is always typechecked, even if there are no classes in the `deriving` clause. Moreover, it typecheck the `via` type /exactly/ once and no more, even if there are multiple classes in the clause. Note [Recovering from failures in deriving clauses] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Consider what happens if you run this program (from #10684) without DeriveGeneric enabled: data A = A deriving (Show, Generic) data B = B A deriving (Show) Naturally, you'd expect GHC to give an error to the effect of: Can't make a derived instance of `Generic A': You need -XDeriveGeneric to derive an instance for this class And *only* that error, since the other two derived Show instances appear to be independent of this derived Generic instance. Yet GHC also used to give this additional error on the program above: No instance for (Show A) arising from the 'deriving' clause of a data type declaration When deriving the instance for (Show B) This was happening because when GHC encountered any error within a single data type's set of deriving clauses, it would call recoverM and move on to the next data type's deriving clauses. One unfortunate consequence of this design is that if A's derived Generic instance failed, its derived Show instance would be skipped entirely, leading to the "No instance for (Show A)" error cascade. The solution to this problem is to push through uses of recoverM to the level of the individual derived classes in a particular data type's set of deriving clauses. That is, if you have: newtype C = C D deriving (E, F, G) Then instead of processing instances E through M under the scope of a single recoverM, as in the following pseudocode: recoverM (pure Nothing) $ mapM derivePred [E, F, G] We instead use recoverM in each iteration of the loop: mapM (recoverM (pure Nothing) . derivePred) [E, F, G] And then process each class individually, under its own recoverM scope. That way, failure to derive one class doesn't cancel out other classes in the same set of clause-derived classes. -} ------------------------------------------------------------------ deriveStandalone :: LDerivDecl GhcRn -> TcM (Maybe EarlyDerivSpec) -- Process a single standalone deriving declaration -- e.g. deriving instance Show a => Show (T a) -- Rather like tcLocalInstDecl -- -- This returns a Maybe because the user might try to derive Typeable, which is -- a no-op nowadays. deriveStandalone (L loc (DerivDecl _ deriv_ty mb_lderiv_strat overlap_mode)) = setSrcSpan loc $ addErrCtxt (standaloneCtxt deriv_ty) $ do { traceTc "Standalone deriving decl for" (ppr deriv_ty) ; let ctxt = TcOrigin.InstDeclCtxt True ; traceTc "Deriving strategy (standalone deriving)" $ vcat [ppr mb_lderiv_strat, ppr deriv_ty] ; (mb_lderiv_strat, via_tvs) <- tcDerivStrategy mb_lderiv_strat ; (cls_tvs, deriv_ctxt, cls, inst_tys) <- tcExtendTyVarEnv via_tvs $ tcStandaloneDerivInstType ctxt deriv_ty ; let mb_deriv_strat = fmap unLoc mb_lderiv_strat tvs = via_tvs ++ cls_tvs -- See Note [Unify kinds in deriving] ; (tvs', deriv_ctxt', inst_tys', mb_deriv_strat') <- case mb_deriv_strat of -- Perform an additional unification with the kind of the `via` -- type and the result of the previous kind unification. Just (ViaStrategy via_ty) -- This unification must be performed on the last element of -- inst_tys, but we have not yet checked for this property. -- (This is done later in expectNonNullaryClsArgs). For now, -- simply do nothing if inst_tys is empty, since -- expectNonNullaryClsArgs will error later if this -- is the case. | Just inst_ty <- lastMaybe inst_tys -> do let via_kind = tcTypeKind via_ty inst_ty_kind = tcTypeKind inst_ty mb_match = tcUnifyTy inst_ty_kind via_kind checkTc (isJust mb_match) (derivingViaKindErr cls inst_ty_kind via_ty via_kind) let Just kind_subst = mb_match ki_subst_range = getTCvSubstRangeFVs kind_subst -- See Note [Unification of two kind variables in deriving] unmapped_tkvs = filter (\v -> v `notElemTCvSubst` kind_subst && not (v `elemVarSet` ki_subst_range)) tvs (subst, _) = substTyVarBndrs kind_subst unmapped_tkvs (final_deriv_ctxt, final_deriv_ctxt_tys) = case deriv_ctxt of InferContext wc -> (InferContext wc, []) SupplyContext theta -> let final_theta = substTheta subst theta in (SupplyContext final_theta, final_theta) final_inst_tys = substTys subst inst_tys final_via_ty = substTy subst via_ty -- See Note [Floating `via` type variables] final_tvs = tyCoVarsOfTypesWellScoped $ final_deriv_ctxt_tys ++ final_inst_tys ++ [final_via_ty] pure ( final_tvs, final_deriv_ctxt, final_inst_tys , Just (ViaStrategy final_via_ty) ) _ -> pure (tvs, deriv_ctxt, inst_tys, mb_deriv_strat) ; traceTc "Standalone deriving;" $ vcat [ text "tvs':" <+> ppr tvs' , text "mb_deriv_strat':" <+> ppr mb_deriv_strat' , text "deriv_ctxt':" <+> ppr deriv_ctxt' , text "cls:" <+> ppr cls , text "inst_tys':" <+> ppr inst_tys' ] -- C.f. TcInstDcls.tcLocalInstDecl1 ; if className cls == typeableClassName then do warnUselessTypeable return Nothing else Just <$> mkEqnHelp (fmap unLoc overlap_mode) tvs' cls inst_tys' deriv_ctxt' mb_deriv_strat' } deriveStandalone (L _ (XDerivDecl nec)) = noExtCon nec -- Typecheck the type in a standalone deriving declaration. -- -- This may appear dense, but it's mostly huffing and puffing to recognize -- the special case of a type with an extra-constraints wildcard context, e.g., -- -- deriving instance _ => Eq (Foo a) -- -- If there is such a wildcard, we typecheck this as if we had written -- @deriving instance Eq (Foo a)@, and return @'InferContext' ('Just' loc)@, -- as the 'DerivContext', where loc is the location of the wildcard used for -- error reporting. This indicates that we should infer the context as if we -- were deriving Eq via a deriving clause -- (see Note [Inferring the instance context] in TcDerivInfer). -- -- If there is no wildcard, then proceed as normal, and instead return -- @'SupplyContext' theta@, where theta is the typechecked context. -- -- Note that this will never return @'InferContext' 'Nothing'@, as that can -- only happen with @deriving@ clauses. tcStandaloneDerivInstType :: UserTypeCtxt -> LHsSigWcType GhcRn -> TcM ([TyVar], DerivContext, Class, [Type]) tcStandaloneDerivInstType ctxt (HsWC { hswc_body = deriv_ty@(HsIB { hsib_ext = vars , hsib_body = deriv_ty_body })}) | (tvs, theta, rho) <- splitLHsSigmaTyInvis deriv_ty_body , L _ [wc_pred] <- theta , L wc_span (HsWildCardTy _) <- ignoreParens wc_pred = do dfun_ty <- tcHsClsInstType ctxt $ HsIB { hsib_ext = vars , hsib_body = L (getLoc deriv_ty_body) $ HsForAllTy { hst_fvf = ForallInvis , hst_bndrs = tvs , hst_xforall = noExtField , hst_body = rho }} let (tvs, _theta, cls, inst_tys) = tcSplitDFunTy dfun_ty pure (tvs, InferContext (Just wc_span), cls, inst_tys) | otherwise = do dfun_ty <- tcHsClsInstType ctxt deriv_ty let (tvs, theta, cls, inst_tys) = tcSplitDFunTy dfun_ty pure (tvs, SupplyContext theta, cls, inst_tys) tcStandaloneDerivInstType _ (HsWC _ (XHsImplicitBndrs nec)) = noExtCon nec tcStandaloneDerivInstType _ (XHsWildCardBndrs nec) = noExtCon nec warnUselessTypeable :: TcM () warnUselessTypeable = do { warn <- woptM Opt_WarnDerivingTypeable ; when warn $ addWarnTc (Reason Opt_WarnDerivingTypeable) $ text "Deriving" <+> quotes (ppr typeableClassName) <+> text "has no effect: all types now auto-derive Typeable" } ------------------------------------------------------------------ deriveTyData :: TyCon -> [Type] -- LHS of data or data instance -- Can be a data instance, hence [Type] args -- and in that case the TyCon is the /family/ tycon -> Maybe (DerivStrategy GhcTc) -- The optional deriving strategy -> [TyVar] -- The type variables bound by the derived class -> Class -- The derived class -> [Type] -- The derived class's arguments -> Kind -- The function argument in the derived class's kind. -- (e.g., if `deriving Functor`, this would be -- `Type -> Type` since -- `Functor :: (Type -> Type) -> Constraint`) -> TcM EarlyDerivSpec -- The deriving clause of a data or newtype declaration -- I.e. not standalone deriving deriveTyData tc tc_args mb_deriv_strat deriv_tvs cls cls_tys cls_arg_kind = do { -- Given data T a b c = ... deriving( C d ), -- we want to drop type variables from T so that (C d (T a)) is well-kinded let (arg_kinds, _) = splitFunTys cls_arg_kind n_args_to_drop = length arg_kinds n_args_to_keep = length tc_args - n_args_to_drop -- See Note [tc_args and tycon arity] (tc_args_to_keep, args_to_drop) = splitAt n_args_to_keep tc_args inst_ty_kind = tcTypeKind (mkTyConApp tc tc_args_to_keep) -- Match up the kinds, and apply the resulting kind substitution -- to the types. See Note [Unify kinds in deriving] -- We are assuming the tycon tyvars and the class tyvars are distinct mb_match = tcUnifyTy inst_ty_kind cls_arg_kind enough_args = n_args_to_keep >= 0 -- Check that the result really is well-kinded ; checkTc (enough_args && isJust mb_match) (derivingKindErr tc cls cls_tys cls_arg_kind enough_args) ; let -- Returns a singleton-element list if using ViaStrategy and an -- empty list otherwise. Useful for free-variable calculations. deriv_strat_tys :: Maybe (DerivStrategy GhcTc) -> [Type] deriv_strat_tys = foldMap (foldDerivStrategy [] (:[])) propagate_subst kind_subst tkvs' cls_tys' tc_args' mb_deriv_strat' = (final_tkvs, final_cls_tys, final_tc_args, final_mb_deriv_strat) where ki_subst_range = getTCvSubstRangeFVs kind_subst -- See Note [Unification of two kind variables in deriving] unmapped_tkvs = filter (\v -> v `notElemTCvSubst` kind_subst && not (v `elemVarSet` ki_subst_range)) tkvs' (subst, _) = substTyVarBndrs kind_subst unmapped_tkvs final_tc_args = substTys subst tc_args' final_cls_tys = substTys subst cls_tys' final_mb_deriv_strat = fmap (mapDerivStrategy (substTy subst)) mb_deriv_strat' -- See Note [Floating `via` type variables] final_tkvs = tyCoVarsOfTypesWellScoped $ final_cls_tys ++ final_tc_args ++ deriv_strat_tys final_mb_deriv_strat ; let tkvs = scopedSort $ fvVarList $ unionFV (tyCoFVsOfTypes tc_args_to_keep) (FV.mkFVs deriv_tvs) Just kind_subst = mb_match (tkvs', cls_tys', tc_args', mb_deriv_strat') = propagate_subst kind_subst tkvs cls_tys tc_args_to_keep mb_deriv_strat -- See Note [Unify kinds in deriving] ; (final_tkvs, final_cls_tys, final_tc_args, final_mb_deriv_strat) <- case mb_deriv_strat' of -- Perform an additional unification with the kind of the `via` -- type and the result of the previous kind unification. Just (ViaStrategy via_ty) -> do let via_kind = tcTypeKind via_ty inst_ty_kind = tcTypeKind (mkTyConApp tc tc_args') via_match = tcUnifyTy inst_ty_kind via_kind checkTc (isJust via_match) (derivingViaKindErr cls inst_ty_kind via_ty via_kind) let Just via_subst = via_match pure $ propagate_subst via_subst tkvs' cls_tys' tc_args' mb_deriv_strat' _ -> pure (tkvs', cls_tys', tc_args', mb_deriv_strat') ; traceTc "deriveTyData 1" $ vcat [ ppr final_mb_deriv_strat, pprTyVars deriv_tvs, ppr tc, ppr tc_args , pprTyVars (tyCoVarsOfTypesList tc_args) , ppr n_args_to_keep, ppr n_args_to_drop , ppr inst_ty_kind, ppr cls_arg_kind, ppr mb_match , ppr final_tc_args, ppr final_cls_tys ] ; traceTc "deriveTyData 2" $ vcat [ ppr final_tkvs ] ; let final_tc_app = mkTyConApp tc final_tc_args final_cls_args = final_cls_tys ++ [final_tc_app] ; checkTc (allDistinctTyVars (mkVarSet final_tkvs) args_to_drop) -- (a, b, c) (derivingEtaErr cls final_cls_tys final_tc_app) -- Check that -- (a) The args to drop are all type variables; eg reject: -- data instance T a Int = .... deriving( Monad ) -- (b) The args to drop are all *distinct* type variables; eg reject: -- class C (a :: * -> * -> *) where ... -- data instance T a a = ... deriving( C ) -- (c) The type class args, or remaining tycon args, -- do not mention any of the dropped type variables -- newtype T a s = ... deriving( ST s ) -- newtype instance K a a = ... deriving( Monad ) -- -- It is vital that the implementation of allDistinctTyVars -- expand any type synonyms. -- See Note [Eta-reducing type synonyms] ; checkValidInstHead DerivClauseCtxt cls final_cls_args -- Check that we aren't deriving an instance of a magical -- type like (~) or Coercible (#14916). ; spec <- mkEqnHelp Nothing final_tkvs cls final_cls_args (InferContext Nothing) final_mb_deriv_strat ; traceTc "deriveTyData 3" (ppr spec) ; return spec } {- Note [tc_args and tycon arity] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ You might wonder if we could use (tyConArity tc) at this point, rather than (length tc_args). But for data families the two can differ! The tc and tc_args passed into 'deriveTyData' come from 'deriveClause' which in turn gets them from 'tyConFamInstSig_maybe' which in turn gets them from DataFamInstTyCon: | DataFamInstTyCon -- See Note [Data type families] (CoAxiom Unbranched) TyCon -- The family TyCon [Type] -- Argument types (mentions the tyConTyVars of this TyCon) -- No shorter in length than the tyConTyVars of the family TyCon -- How could it be longer? See [Arity of data families] in FamInstEnv Notice that the arg tys might not be the same as the family tycon arity (= length tyConTyVars). Note [Unify kinds in deriving] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Consider (#8534) data T a b = MkT a deriving( Functor ) -- where Functor :: (*->*) -> Constraint So T :: forall k. * -> k -> *. We want to get instance Functor (T * (a:*)) where ... Notice the '*' argument to T. Moreover, as well as instantiating T's kind arguments, we may need to instantiate C's kind args. Consider (#8865): newtype T a b = MkT (Either a b) deriving( Category ) where Category :: forall k. (k -> k -> *) -> Constraint We need to generate the instance instance Category * (Either a) where ... Notice the '*' argument to Category. So we need to * drop arguments from (T a b) to match the number of arrows in the (last argument of the) class; * and then *unify* kind of the remaining type against the expected kind, to figure out how to instantiate C's and T's kind arguments. In the two examples, * we unify kind-of( T k (a:k) ) ~ kind-of( Functor ) i.e. (k -> *) ~ (* -> *) to find k:=*. yielding k:=* * we unify kind-of( Either ) ~ kind-of( Category ) i.e. (* -> * -> *) ~ (k -> k -> k) yielding k:=* Now we get a kind substitution. We then need to: 1. Remove the substituted-out kind variables from the quantified kind vars 2. Apply the substitution to the kinds of quantified *type* vars (and extend the substitution to reflect this change) 3. Apply that extended substitution to the non-dropped args (types and kinds) of the type and class Forgetting step (2) caused #8893: data V a = V [a] deriving Functor data P (x::k->*) (a:k) = P (x a) deriving Functor data C (x::k->*) (a:k) = C (V (P x a)) deriving Functor When deriving Functor for P, we unify k to *, but we then want an instance $df :: forall (x:*->*). Functor x => Functor (P * (x:*->*)) and similarly for C. Notice the modified kind of x, both at binding and occurrence sites. This can lead to some surprising results when *visible* kind binder is unified (in contrast to the above examples, in which only non-visible kind binders were considered). Consider this example from #11732: data T k (a :: k) = MkT deriving Functor Since unification yields k:=*, this results in a generated instance of: instance Functor (T *) where ... which looks odd at first glance, since one might expect the instance head to be of the form Functor (T k). Indeed, one could envision an alternative generated instance of: instance (k ~ *) => Functor (T k) where But this does not typecheck by design: kind equalities are not allowed to be bound in types, only terms. But in essence, the two instance declarations are entirely equivalent, since even though (T k) matches any kind k, the only possibly value for k is *, since anything else is ill-typed. As a result, we can just as comfortably use (T *). Another way of thinking about is: deriving clauses often infer constraints. For example: data S a = S a deriving Eq infers an (Eq a) constraint in the derived instance. By analogy, when we are deriving Functor, we might infer an equality constraint (e.g., k ~ *). The only distinction is that GHC instantiates equality constraints directly during the deriving process. Another quirk of this design choice manifests when typeclasses have visible kind parameters. Consider this code (also from #11732): class Cat k (cat :: k -> k -> *) where catId :: cat a a catComp :: cat b c -> cat a b -> cat a c instance Cat * (->) where catId = id catComp = (.) newtype Fun a b = Fun (a -> b) deriving (Cat k) Even though we requested a derived instance of the form (Cat k Fun), the kind unification will actually generate (Cat * Fun) (i.e., the same thing as if the user wrote deriving (Cat *)). What happens with DerivingVia, when you have yet another type? Consider: newtype Foo (a :: Type) = MkFoo (Proxy a) deriving Functor via Proxy As before, we unify the kind of Foo (* -> *) with the kind of the argument to Functor (* -> *). But that's not enough: the `via` type, Proxy, has the kind (k -> *), which is more general than what we want. So we must additionally unify (k -> *) with (* -> *). Currently, all of this unification is implemented kludgily with the pure unifier, which is rather tiresome. #14331 lays out a plan for how this might be made cleaner. Note [Unification of two kind variables in deriving] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ As a special case of the Note above, it is possible to derive an instance of a poly-kinded typeclass for a poly-kinded datatype. For example: class Category (cat :: k -> k -> *) where newtype T (c :: k -> k -> *) a b = MkT (c a b) deriving Category This case is suprisingly tricky. To see why, let's write out what instance GHC will attempt to derive (using -fprint-explicit-kinds syntax): instance Category k1 (T k2 c) where ... GHC will attempt to unify k1 and k2, which produces a substitution (kind_subst) that looks like [k2 :-> k1]. Importantly, we need to apply this substitution to the type variable binder for c, since its kind is (k2 -> k2 -> *). We used to accomplish this by doing the following: unmapped_tkvs = filter (`notElemTCvSubst` kind_subst) all_tkvs (subst, _) = substTyVarBndrs kind_subst unmapped_tkvs Where all_tkvs contains all kind variables in the class and instance types (in this case, all_tkvs = [k1,k2]). But since kind_subst only has one mapping, this results in unmapped_tkvs being [k1], and as a consequence, k1 gets mapped to another kind variable in subst! That is, subst = [k2 :-> k1, k1 :-> k_new]. This is bad, because applying that substitution yields the following instance: instance Category k_new (T k1 c) where ... In other words, keeping k1 in unmapped_tvks taints the substitution, resulting in an ill-kinded instance (this caused #11837). To prevent this, we need to filter out any variable from all_tkvs which either 1. Appears in the domain of kind_subst. notElemTCvSubst checks this. 2. Appears in the range of kind_subst. To do this, we compute the free variable set of the range of kind_subst with getTCvSubstRangeFVs, and check if a kind variable appears in that set. Note [Eta-reducing type synonyms] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ One can instantiate a type in a data family instance with a type synonym that mentions other type variables: type Const a b = a data family Fam (f :: * -> *) (a :: *) newtype instance Fam f (Const a f) = Fam (f a) deriving Functor It is also possible to define kind synonyms, and they can mention other types in a datatype declaration. For example, type Const a b = a newtype T f (a :: Const * f) = T (f a) deriving Functor When deriving, we need to perform eta-reduction analysis to ensure that none of the eta-reduced type variables are mentioned elsewhere in the declaration. But we need to be careful, because if we don't expand through the Const type synonym, we will mistakenly believe that f is an eta-reduced type variable and fail to derive Functor, even though the code above is correct (see #11416, where this was first noticed). For this reason, we expand the type synonyms in the eta-reduced types before doing any analysis. Note [Floating `via` type variables] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ When generating a derived instance, it will be of the form: instance forall ???. C c_args (D d_args) where ... To fill in ???, GHC computes the free variables of `c_args` and `d_args`. `DerivingVia` adds an extra wrinkle to this formula, since we must also include the variables bound by the `via` type when computing the binders used to fill in ???. This might seem strange, since if a `via` type binds any type variables, then in almost all scenarios it will appear free in `c_args` or `d_args`. There are certain corner cases where this does not hold, however, such as in the following example (adapted from #15831): newtype Age = MkAge Int deriving Eq via Const Int a In this example, the `via` type binds the type variable `a`, but `a` appears nowhere in `Eq Age`. Nevertheless, we include it in the generated instance: instance forall a. Eq Age where (==) = coerce @(Const Int a -> Const Int a -> Bool) @(Age -> Age -> Bool) (==) The use of `forall a` is certainly required here, since the `a` in `Const Int a` would not be in scope otherwise. This instance is somewhat strange in that nothing in the instance head `Eq Age` ever determines what `a` will be, so any code that uses this instance will invariably instantiate `a` to be `Any`. We refer to this property of `a` as being a "floating" `via` type variable. Programs with floating `via` type variables are the only known class of program in which the `via` type quantifies type variables that aren't mentioned in the instance head in the generated instance. Fortunately, the choice to instantiate floating `via` type variables to `Any` is one that is completely transparent to the user (since the instance will work as expected regardless of what `a` is instantiated to), so we decide to permit them. An alternative design would make programs with floating `via` variables illegal, by requiring that every variable mentioned in the `via` type is also mentioned in the data header or the derived class. That restriction would require the user to pick a particular type (the choice does not matter); for example: newtype Age = MkAge Int -- deriving Eq via Const Int a -- Floating 'a' deriving Eq via Const Int () -- Choose a=() deriving Eq via Const Int Any -- Choose a=Any No expressiveness would be lost thereby, but stylistically it seems preferable to allow a type variable to indicate "it doesn't matter". Note that by quantifying the `a` in `forall a. Eq Age`, we are deferring the work of instantiating `a` to `Any` at every use site of the instance. An alternative approach would be to generate an instance that directly defaulted to `Any`: instance Eq Age where (==) = coerce @(Const Int Any -> Const Int Any -> Bool) @(Age -> Age -> Bool) (==) We do not implement this approach since it would require a nontrivial amount of implementation effort to substitute `Any` for the floating `via` type variables, and since the end result isn't distinguishable from the former instance (at least from the user's perspective), the amount of engineering required to obtain the latter instance just isn't worth it. -} mkEqnHelp :: Maybe OverlapMode -> [TyVar] -> Class -> [Type] -> DerivContext -- SupplyContext => context supplied (standalone deriving) -- InferContext => context inferred (deriving on data decl, or -- standalone deriving decl with a wildcard) -> Maybe (DerivStrategy GhcTc) -> TcRn EarlyDerivSpec -- Make the EarlyDerivSpec for an instance -- forall tvs. theta => cls (tys ++ [ty]) -- where the 'theta' is optional (that's the Maybe part) -- Assumes that this declaration is well-kinded mkEqnHelp overlap_mode tvs cls cls_args deriv_ctxt deriv_strat = do is_boot <- tcIsHsBootOrSig when is_boot $ bale_out (text "Cannot derive instances in hs-boot files" $+$ text "Write an instance declaration instead") runReaderT mk_eqn deriv_env where deriv_env = DerivEnv { denv_overlap_mode = overlap_mode , denv_tvs = tvs , denv_cls = cls , denv_inst_tys = cls_args , denv_ctxt = deriv_ctxt , denv_strat = deriv_strat } bale_out msg = failWithTc $ derivingThingErr False cls cls_args deriv_strat msg mk_eqn :: DerivM EarlyDerivSpec mk_eqn = do DerivEnv { denv_inst_tys = cls_args , denv_strat = mb_strat } <- ask case mb_strat of Just StockStrategy -> do (cls_tys, inst_ty) <- expectNonNullaryClsArgs cls_args dit <- expectAlgTyConApp cls_tys inst_ty mk_eqn_stock dit Just AnyclassStrategy -> mk_eqn_anyclass Just (ViaStrategy via_ty) -> do (cls_tys, inst_ty) <- expectNonNullaryClsArgs cls_args mk_eqn_via cls_tys inst_ty via_ty Just NewtypeStrategy -> do (cls_tys, inst_ty) <- expectNonNullaryClsArgs cls_args dit <- expectAlgTyConApp cls_tys inst_ty unless (isNewTyCon (dit_rep_tc dit)) $ derivingThingFailWith False gndNonNewtypeErr mkNewTypeEqn True dit Nothing -> mk_eqn_no_strategy -- @expectNonNullaryClsArgs inst_tys@ checks if @inst_tys@ is non-empty. -- If so, return @(init inst_tys, last inst_tys)@. -- Otherwise, throw an error message. -- See @Note [DerivEnv and DerivSpecMechanism]@ in "TcDerivUtils" for why this -- property is important. expectNonNullaryClsArgs :: [Type] -> DerivM ([Type], Type) expectNonNullaryClsArgs inst_tys = maybe (derivingThingFailWith False derivingNullaryErr) pure $ snocView inst_tys -- @expectAlgTyConApp cls_tys inst_ty@ checks if @inst_ty@ is an application -- of an algebraic type constructor. If so, return a 'DerivInstTys' consisting -- of @cls_tys@ and the constituent pars of @inst_ty@. -- Otherwise, throw an error message. -- See @Note [DerivEnv and DerivSpecMechanism]@ in "TcDerivUtils" for why this -- property is important. expectAlgTyConApp :: [Type] -- All but the last argument to the class in a -- derived instance -> Type -- The last argument to the class in a -- derived instance -> DerivM DerivInstTys expectAlgTyConApp cls_tys inst_ty = do fam_envs <- lift tcGetFamInstEnvs case mk_deriv_inst_tys_maybe fam_envs cls_tys inst_ty of Nothing -> derivingThingFailWith False $ text "The last argument of the instance must be a" <+> text "data or newtype application" Just dit -> do expectNonDataFamTyCon dit pure dit -- @expectNonDataFamTyCon dit@ checks if @dit_rep_tc dit@ is a representation -- type constructor for a data family instance, and if not, -- throws an error message. -- See @Note [DerivEnv and DerivSpecMechanism]@ in "TcDerivUtils" for why this -- property is important. expectNonDataFamTyCon :: DerivInstTys -> DerivM () expectNonDataFamTyCon (DerivInstTys { dit_tc = tc , dit_tc_args = tc_args , dit_rep_tc = rep_tc }) = -- If it's still a data family, the lookup failed; i.e no instance exists when (isDataFamilyTyCon rep_tc) $ derivingThingFailWith False $ text "No family instance for" <+> quotes (pprTypeApp tc tc_args) mk_deriv_inst_tys_maybe :: FamInstEnvs -> [Type] -> Type -> Maybe DerivInstTys mk_deriv_inst_tys_maybe fam_envs cls_tys inst_ty = fmap lookup $ tcSplitTyConApp_maybe inst_ty where lookup :: (TyCon, [Type]) -> DerivInstTys lookup (tc, tc_args) = -- Find the instance of a data family -- Note [Looking up family instances for deriving] let (rep_tc, rep_tc_args, _co) = tcLookupDataFamInst fam_envs tc tc_args in DerivInstTys { dit_cls_tys = cls_tys , dit_tc = tc , dit_tc_args = tc_args , dit_rep_tc = rep_tc , dit_rep_tc_args = rep_tc_args } {- Note [Looking up family instances for deriving] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ tcLookupFamInstExact is an auxiliary lookup wrapper which requires that looked-up family instances exist. If called with a vanilla tycon, the old type application is simply returned. If we have data instance F () = ... deriving Eq data instance F () = ... deriving Eq then tcLookupFamInstExact will be confused by the two matches; but that can't happen because tcInstDecls1 doesn't call tcDeriving if there are any overlaps. There are two other things that might go wrong with the lookup. First, we might see a standalone deriving clause deriving Eq (F ()) when there is no data instance F () in scope. Note that it's OK to have data instance F [a] = ... deriving Eq (F [(a,b)]) where the match is not exact; the same holds for ordinary data types with standalone deriving declarations. Note [Deriving, type families, and partial applications] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ When there are no type families, it's quite easy: newtype S a = MkS [a] -- :CoS :: S ~ [] -- Eta-reduced instance Eq [a] => Eq (S a) -- by coercion sym (Eq (:CoS a)) : Eq [a] ~ Eq (S a) instance Monad [] => Monad S -- by coercion sym (Monad :CoS) : Monad [] ~ Monad S When type familes are involved it's trickier: data family T a b newtype instance T Int a = MkT [a] deriving( Eq, Monad ) -- :RT is the representation type for (T Int a) -- :Co:RT :: :RT ~ [] -- Eta-reduced! -- :CoF:RT a :: T Int a ~ :RT a -- Also eta-reduced! instance Eq [a] => Eq (T Int a) -- easy by coercion -- d1 :: Eq [a] -- d2 :: Eq (T Int a) = d1 |> Eq (sym (:Co:RT a ; :coF:RT a)) instance Monad [] => Monad (T Int) -- only if we can eta reduce??? -- d1 :: Monad [] -- d2 :: Monad (T Int) = d1 |> Monad (sym (:Co:RT ; :coF:RT)) Note the need for the eta-reduced rule axioms. After all, we can write it out instance Monad [] => Monad (T Int) -- only if we can eta reduce??? return x = MkT [x] ... etc ... See Note [Eta reduction for data families] in FamInstEnv %************************************************************************ %* * Deriving data types * * ************************************************************************ -} -- Once the DerivSpecMechanism is known, we can finally produce an -- EarlyDerivSpec from it. mk_eqn_from_mechanism :: DerivSpecMechanism -> DerivM EarlyDerivSpec mk_eqn_from_mechanism mechanism = do DerivEnv { denv_overlap_mode = overlap_mode , denv_tvs = tvs , denv_cls = cls , denv_inst_tys = inst_tys , denv_ctxt = deriv_ctxt } <- ask doDerivInstErrorChecks1 mechanism loc <- lift getSrcSpanM dfun_name <- lift $ newDFunName cls inst_tys loc case deriv_ctxt of InferContext wildcard -> do { (inferred_constraints, tvs', inst_tys') <- inferConstraints mechanism ; return $ InferTheta $ DS { ds_loc = loc , ds_name = dfun_name, ds_tvs = tvs' , ds_cls = cls, ds_tys = inst_tys' , ds_theta = inferred_constraints , ds_overlap = overlap_mode , ds_standalone_wildcard = wildcard , ds_mechanism = mechanism } } SupplyContext theta -> return $ GivenTheta $ DS { ds_loc = loc , ds_name = dfun_name, ds_tvs = tvs , ds_cls = cls, ds_tys = inst_tys , ds_theta = theta , ds_overlap = overlap_mode , ds_standalone_wildcard = Nothing , ds_mechanism = mechanism } mk_eqn_stock :: DerivInstTys -- Information about the arguments to the class -> DerivM EarlyDerivSpec mk_eqn_stock dit@(DerivInstTys { dit_cls_tys = cls_tys , dit_tc = tc , dit_rep_tc = rep_tc }) = do DerivEnv { denv_cls = cls , denv_ctxt = deriv_ctxt } <- ask dflags <- getDynFlags case checkOriginativeSideConditions dflags deriv_ctxt cls cls_tys tc rep_tc of CanDeriveStock gen_fn -> mk_eqn_from_mechanism $ DerivSpecStock { dsm_stock_dit = dit , dsm_stock_gen_fn = gen_fn } StockClassError msg -> derivingThingFailWith False msg _ -> derivingThingFailWith False (nonStdErr cls) mk_eqn_anyclass :: DerivM EarlyDerivSpec mk_eqn_anyclass = do dflags <- getDynFlags case canDeriveAnyClass dflags of IsValid -> mk_eqn_from_mechanism DerivSpecAnyClass NotValid msg -> derivingThingFailWith False msg mk_eqn_newtype :: DerivInstTys -- Information about the arguments to the class -> Type -- The newtype's representation type -> DerivM EarlyDerivSpec mk_eqn_newtype dit rep_ty = mk_eqn_from_mechanism $ DerivSpecNewtype { dsm_newtype_dit = dit , dsm_newtype_rep_ty = rep_ty } mk_eqn_via :: [Type] -- All arguments to the class besides the last -> Type -- The last argument to the class -> Type -- The @via@ type -> DerivM EarlyDerivSpec mk_eqn_via cls_tys inst_ty via_ty = mk_eqn_from_mechanism $ DerivSpecVia { dsm_via_cls_tys = cls_tys , dsm_via_inst_ty = inst_ty , dsm_via_ty = via_ty } -- Derive an instance without a user-requested deriving strategy. This uses -- heuristics to determine which deriving strategy to use. -- See Note [Deriving strategies]. mk_eqn_no_strategy :: DerivM EarlyDerivSpec mk_eqn_no_strategy = do DerivEnv { denv_cls = cls , denv_inst_tys = cls_args } <- ask fam_envs <- lift tcGetFamInstEnvs -- First, check if the last argument is an application of a type constructor. -- If not, fall back to DeriveAnyClass. if | Just (cls_tys, inst_ty) <- snocView cls_args , Just dit <- mk_deriv_inst_tys_maybe fam_envs cls_tys inst_ty -> if | isNewTyCon (dit_rep_tc dit) -- We have a dedicated code path for newtypes (see the -- documentation for mkNewTypeEqn as to why this is the case) -> mkNewTypeEqn False dit | otherwise -> do -- Otherwise, our only other options are stock or anyclass. -- If it is stock, we must confirm that the last argument's -- type constructor is algebraic. -- See Note [DerivEnv and DerivSpecMechanism] in TcDerivUtils whenIsJust (hasStockDeriving cls) $ \_ -> expectNonDataFamTyCon dit mk_eqn_originative dit | otherwise -> mk_eqn_anyclass where -- Use heuristics (checkOriginativeSideConditions) to determine whether -- stock or anyclass deriving should be used. mk_eqn_originative :: DerivInstTys -> DerivM EarlyDerivSpec mk_eqn_originative dit@(DerivInstTys { dit_cls_tys = cls_tys , dit_tc = tc , dit_rep_tc = rep_tc }) = do DerivEnv { denv_cls = cls , denv_ctxt = deriv_ctxt } <- ask dflags <- getDynFlags -- See Note [Deriving instances for classes themselves] let dac_error msg | isClassTyCon rep_tc = quotes (ppr tc) <+> text "is a type class," <+> text "and can only have a derived instance" $+$ text "if DeriveAnyClass is enabled" | otherwise = nonStdErr cls $$ msg case checkOriginativeSideConditions dflags deriv_ctxt cls cls_tys tc rep_tc of NonDerivableClass msg -> derivingThingFailWith False (dac_error msg) StockClassError msg -> derivingThingFailWith False msg CanDeriveStock gen_fn -> mk_eqn_from_mechanism $ DerivSpecStock { dsm_stock_dit = dit , dsm_stock_gen_fn = gen_fn } CanDeriveAnyClass -> mk_eqn_from_mechanism DerivSpecAnyClass {- ************************************************************************ * * Deriving instances for newtypes * * ************************************************************************ -} -- Derive an instance for a newtype. We put this logic into its own function -- because -- -- (a) When no explicit deriving strategy is requested, we have special -- heuristics for newtypes to determine which deriving strategy should -- actually be used. See Note [Deriving strategies]. -- (b) We make an effort to give error messages specifically tailored to -- newtypes. mkNewTypeEqn :: Bool -- Was this instance derived using an explicit @newtype@ -- deriving strategy? -> DerivInstTys -> DerivM EarlyDerivSpec mkNewTypeEqn newtype_strat dit@(DerivInstTys { dit_cls_tys = cls_tys , dit_tc = tycon , dit_rep_tc = rep_tycon , dit_rep_tc_args = rep_tc_args }) -- Want: instance (...) => cls (cls_tys ++ [tycon tc_args]) where ... = do DerivEnv { denv_cls = cls , denv_ctxt = deriv_ctxt } <- ask dflags <- getDynFlags let newtype_deriving = xopt LangExt.GeneralizedNewtypeDeriving dflags deriveAnyClass = xopt LangExt.DeriveAnyClass dflags bale_out = derivingThingFailWith newtype_deriving non_std = nonStdErr cls suggest_gnd = text "Try GeneralizedNewtypeDeriving for GHC's" <+> text "newtype-deriving extension" -- Here is the plan for newtype derivings. We see -- newtype T a1...an = MkT (t ak+1...an) -- deriving (.., C s1 .. sm, ...) -- where t is a type, -- ak+1...an is a suffix of a1..an, and are all tyvars -- ak+1...an do not occur free in t, nor in the s1..sm -- (C s1 ... sm) is a *partial applications* of class C -- with the last parameter missing -- (T a1 .. ak) matches the kind of C's last argument -- (and hence so does t) -- The latter kind-check has been done by deriveTyData already, -- and tc_args are already trimmed -- -- We generate the instance -- instance forall ({a1..ak} u fvs(s1..sm)). -- C s1 .. sm t => C s1 .. sm (T a1...ak) -- where T a1...ap is the partial application of -- the LHS of the correct kind and p >= k -- -- NB: the variables below are: -- tc_tvs = [a1, ..., an] -- tyvars_to_keep = [a1, ..., ak] -- rep_ty = t ak .. an -- deriv_tvs = fvs(s1..sm) \ tc_tvs -- tys = [s1, ..., sm] -- rep_fn' = t -- -- Running example: newtype T s a = MkT (ST s a) deriving( Monad ) -- We generate the instance -- instance Monad (ST s) => Monad (T s) where nt_eta_arity = newTyConEtadArity rep_tycon -- For newtype T a b = MkT (S a a b), the TyCon -- machinery already eta-reduces the representation type, so -- we know that -- T a ~ S a a -- That's convenient here, because we may have to apply -- it to fewer than its original complement of arguments -- Note [Newtype representation] -- ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ -- Need newTyConRhs (*not* a recursive representation finder) -- to get the representation type. For example -- newtype B = MkB Int -- newtype A = MkA B deriving( Num ) -- We want the Num instance of B, *not* the Num instance of Int, -- when making the Num instance of A! rep_inst_ty = newTyConInstRhs rep_tycon rep_tc_args ------------------------------------------------------------------- -- Figuring out whether we can only do this newtype-deriving thing -- See Note [Determining whether newtype-deriving is appropriate] might_be_newtype_derivable = not (non_coercible_class cls) && eta_ok -- && not (isRecursiveTyCon tycon) -- Note [Recursive newtypes] -- Check that eta reduction is OK eta_ok = rep_tc_args `lengthAtLeast` nt_eta_arity -- The newtype can be eta-reduced to match the number -- of type argument actually supplied -- newtype T a b = MkT (S [a] b) deriving( Monad ) -- Here the 'b' must be the same in the rep type (S [a] b) -- And the [a] must not mention 'b'. That's all handled -- by nt_eta_rity. cant_derive_err = ppUnless eta_ok eta_msg eta_msg = text "cannot eta-reduce the representation type enough" MASSERT( cls_tys `lengthIs` (classArity cls - 1) ) if newtype_strat then -- Since the user explicitly asked for GeneralizedNewtypeDeriving, -- we don't need to perform all of the checks we normally would, -- such as if the class being derived is known to produce ill-roled -- coercions (e.g., Traversable), since we can just derive the -- instance and let it error if need be. -- See Note [Determining whether newtype-deriving is appropriate] if eta_ok && newtype_deriving then mk_eqn_newtype dit rep_inst_ty else bale_out (cant_derive_err $$ if newtype_deriving then empty else suggest_gnd) else if might_be_newtype_derivable && ((newtype_deriving && not deriveAnyClass) || std_class_via_coercible cls) then mk_eqn_newtype dit rep_inst_ty else case checkOriginativeSideConditions dflags deriv_ctxt cls cls_tys tycon rep_tycon of StockClassError msg -- There's a particular corner case where -- -- 1. -XGeneralizedNewtypeDeriving and -XDeriveAnyClass are -- both enabled at the same time -- 2. We're deriving a particular stock derivable class -- (such as Functor) -- -- and the previous cases won't catch it. This fixes the bug -- reported in #10598. | might_be_newtype_derivable && newtype_deriving -> mk_eqn_newtype dit rep_inst_ty -- Otherwise, throw an error for a stock class | might_be_newtype_derivable && not newtype_deriving -> bale_out (msg $$ suggest_gnd) | otherwise -> bale_out msg -- Must use newtype deriving or DeriveAnyClass NonDerivableClass _msg -- Too hard, even with newtype deriving | newtype_deriving -> bale_out cant_derive_err -- Try newtype deriving! -- Here we suggest GeneralizedNewtypeDeriving even in cases -- where it may not be applicable. See #9600. | otherwise -> bale_out (non_std $$ suggest_gnd) -- DeriveAnyClass CanDeriveAnyClass -> do -- If both DeriveAnyClass and GeneralizedNewtypeDeriving are -- enabled, we take the diplomatic approach of defaulting to -- DeriveAnyClass, but emitting a warning about the choice. -- See Note [Deriving strategies] when (newtype_deriving && deriveAnyClass) $ lift $ whenWOptM Opt_WarnDerivingDefaults $ addWarnTc (Reason Opt_WarnDerivingDefaults) $ sep [ text "Both DeriveAnyClass and" <+> text "GeneralizedNewtypeDeriving are enabled" , text "Defaulting to the DeriveAnyClass strategy" <+> text "for instantiating" <+> ppr cls , text "Use DerivingStrategies to pick" <+> text "a different strategy" ] mk_eqn_from_mechanism DerivSpecAnyClass -- CanDeriveStock CanDeriveStock gen_fn -> mk_eqn_from_mechanism $ DerivSpecStock { dsm_stock_dit = dit , dsm_stock_gen_fn = gen_fn } {- Note [Recursive newtypes] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Newtype deriving works fine, even if the newtype is recursive. e.g. newtype S1 = S1 [T1 ()] newtype T1 a = T1 (StateT S1 IO a ) deriving( Monad ) Remember, too, that type families are currently (conservatively) given a recursive flag, so this also allows newtype deriving to work for type famillies. We used to exclude recursive types, because we had a rather simple minded way of generating the instance decl: newtype A = MkA [A] instance Eq [A] => Eq A -- Makes typechecker loop! But now we require a simple context, so it's ok. Note [Determining whether newtype-deriving is appropriate] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ When we see newtype NT = MkNT Foo deriving C we have to decide how to perform the deriving. Do we do newtype deriving, or do we do normal deriving? In general, we prefer to do newtype deriving wherever possible. So, we try newtype deriving unless there's a glaring reason not to. "Glaring reasons not to" include trying to derive a class for which a coercion-based instance doesn't make sense. These classes are listed in the definition of non_coercible_class. They include Show (since it must show the name of the datatype) and Traversable (since a coercion-based Traversable instance is ill-roled). However, non_coercible_class is ignored if the user explicitly requests to derive an instance with GeneralizedNewtypeDeriving using the newtype deriving strategy. In such a scenario, GHC will unquestioningly try to derive the instance via coercions (even if the final generated code is ill-roled!). See Note [Deriving strategies]. Note that newtype deriving might fail, even after we commit to it. This is because the derived instance uses `coerce`, which must satisfy its `Coercible` constraint. This is different than other deriving scenarios, where we're sure that the resulting instance will type-check. Note [GND and associated type families] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ It's possible to use GeneralizedNewtypeDeriving (GND) to derive instances for classes with associated type families. A general recipe is: class C x y z where type T y z x op :: x -> [y] -> z newtype N a = MkN <rep-type> deriving( C ) =====> instance C x y <rep-type> => C x y (N a) where type T y (N a) x = T y <rep-type> x op = coerce (op :: x -> [y] -> <rep-type>) However, we must watch out for three things: (a) The class must not contain any data families. If it did, we'd have to generate a fresh data constructor name for the derived data family instance, and it's not clear how to do this. (b) Each associated type family's type variables must mention the last type variable of the class. As an example, you wouldn't be able to use GND to derive an instance of this class: class C a b where type T a But you would be able to derive an instance of this class: class C a b where type T b The difference is that in the latter T mentions the last parameter of C (i.e., it mentions b), but the former T does not. If you tried, e.g., newtype Foo x = Foo x deriving (C a) with the former definition of C, you'd end up with something like this: instance C a (Foo x) where type T a = T ??? This T family instance doesn't mention the newtype (or its representation type) at all, so we disallow such constructions with GND. (c) UndecidableInstances might need to be enabled. Here's a case where it is most definitely necessary: class C a where type T a newtype Loop = Loop MkLoop deriving C =====> instance C Loop where type T Loop = T Loop Obviously, T Loop would send the typechecker into a loop. Unfortunately, you might even need UndecidableInstances even in cases where the typechecker would be guaranteed to terminate. For example: instance C Int where type C Int = Int newtype MyInt = MyInt Int deriving C =====> instance C MyInt where type T MyInt = T Int GHC's termination checker isn't sophisticated enough to conclude that the definition of T MyInt terminates, so UndecidableInstances is required. (d) For the time being, we do not allow the last type variable of the class to appear in a /kind/ of an associated type family definition. For instance: class C a where type T1 a -- OK type T2 (x :: a) -- Illegal: a appears in the kind of x type T3 y :: a -- Illegal: a appears in the kind of (T3 y) The reason we disallow this is because our current approach to deriving associated type family instances—i.e., by unwrapping the newtype's type constructor as shown above—is ill-equipped to handle the scenario when the last type variable appears as an implicit argument. In the worst case, allowing the last variable to appear in a kind can result in improper Core being generated (see #14728). There is hope for this feature being added some day, as one could conceivably take a newtype axiom (which witnesses a coercion between a newtype and its representation type) at lift that through each associated type at the Core level. See #14728, comment:3 for a sketch of how this might work. Until then, we disallow this featurette wholesale. The same criteria apply to DerivingVia. ************************************************************************ * * \subsection[TcDeriv-normal-binds]{Bindings for the various classes} * * ************************************************************************ After all the trouble to figure out the required context for the derived instance declarations, all that's left is to chug along to produce them. They will then be shoved into @tcInstDecls2@, which will do all its usual business. There are lots of possibilities for code to generate. Here are various general remarks. PRINCIPLES: \begin{itemize} \item We want derived instances of @Eq@ and @Ord@ (both v common) to be ``you-couldn't-do-better-by-hand'' efficient. \item Deriving @Show@---also pretty common--- should also be reasonable good code. \item Deriving for the other classes isn't that common or that big a deal. \end{itemize} PRAGMATICS: \begin{itemize} \item Deriving @Ord@ is done mostly with the 1.3 @compare@ method. \item Deriving @Eq@ also uses @compare@, if we're deriving @Ord@, too. \item We {\em normally} generate code only for the non-defaulted methods; there are some exceptions for @Eq@ and (especially) @Ord@... \item Sometimes we use a @_con2tag_<tycon>@ function, which returns a data constructor's numeric (@Int#@) tag. These are generated by @gen_tag_n_con_binds@, and the heuristic for deciding if one of these is around is given by @hasCon2TagFun@. The examples under the different sections below will make this clearer. \item Much less often (really just for deriving @Ix@), we use a @_tag2con_<tycon>@ function. See the examples. \item We use the renamer!!! Reason: we're supposed to be producing @LHsBinds Name@ for the methods, but that means producing correctly-uniquified code on the fly. This is entirely possible (the @TcM@ monad has a @UniqueSupply@), but it is painful. So, instead, we produce @MonoBinds RdrName@ then heave 'em through the renamer. What a great hack! \end{itemize} -} -- Generate the InstInfo for the required instance -- plus any auxiliary bindings required genInst :: DerivSpec theta -> TcM (ThetaType -> TcM (InstInfo GhcPs), BagDerivStuff, [Name]) -- We must use continuation-returning style here to get the order in which we -- typecheck family instances and derived instances right. -- See Note [Staging of tcDeriving] genInst spec@(DS { ds_tvs = tvs, ds_mechanism = mechanism , ds_tys = tys, ds_cls = clas, ds_loc = loc , ds_standalone_wildcard = wildcard }) = do (meth_binds, deriv_stuff, unusedNames) <- set_span_and_ctxt $ genDerivStuff mechanism loc clas tys tvs let mk_inst_info theta = set_span_and_ctxt $ do inst_spec <- newDerivClsInst theta spec doDerivInstErrorChecks2 clas inst_spec theta wildcard mechanism traceTc "newder" (ppr inst_spec) return $ InstInfo { iSpec = inst_spec , iBinds = InstBindings { ib_binds = meth_binds , ib_tyvars = map Var.varName tvs , ib_pragmas = [] , ib_extensions = extensions , ib_derived = True } } return (mk_inst_info, deriv_stuff, unusedNames) where extensions :: [LangExt.Extension] extensions | isDerivSpecNewtype mechanism || isDerivSpecVia mechanism -- Both these flags are needed for higher-rank uses of coerce -- See Note [Newtype-deriving instances] in TcGenDeriv = [LangExt.ImpredicativeTypes, LangExt.RankNTypes] | otherwise = [] set_span_and_ctxt :: TcM a -> TcM a set_span_and_ctxt = setSrcSpan loc . addErrCtxt (instDeclCtxt3 clas tys) -- Checks: -- -- * All of the data constructors for a data type are in scope for a -- standalone-derived instance (for `stock` and `newtype` deriving). -- -- * All of the associated type families of a class are suitable for -- GeneralizedNewtypeDeriving or DerivingVia (for `newtype` and `via` -- deriving). doDerivInstErrorChecks1 :: DerivSpecMechanism -> DerivM () doDerivInstErrorChecks1 mechanism = case mechanism of DerivSpecStock{dsm_stock_dit = dit} -> data_cons_in_scope_check dit DerivSpecNewtype{dsm_newtype_dit = dit} -> do atf_coerce_based_error_checks data_cons_in_scope_check dit DerivSpecAnyClass{} -> pure () DerivSpecVia{} -> atf_coerce_based_error_checks where -- When processing a standalone deriving declaration, check that all of the -- constructors for the data type are in scope. For instance: -- -- import M (T) -- deriving stock instance Eq T -- -- This should be rejected, as the derived Eq instance would need to refer -- to the constructors for T, which are not in scope. -- -- Note that the only strategies that require this check are `stock` and -- `newtype`. Neither `anyclass` nor `via` require it as the code that they -- generate does not require using data constructors. data_cons_in_scope_check :: DerivInstTys -> DerivM () data_cons_in_scope_check (DerivInstTys { dit_tc = tc , dit_rep_tc = rep_tc }) = do standalone <- isStandaloneDeriv when standalone $ do let bale_out msg = do err <- derivingThingErrMechanism mechanism msg lift $ failWithTc err rdr_env <- lift getGlobalRdrEnv let data_con_names = map dataConName (tyConDataCons rep_tc) hidden_data_cons = not (isWiredInName (tyConName rep_tc)) && (isAbstractTyCon rep_tc || any not_in_scope data_con_names) not_in_scope dc = isNothing (lookupGRE_Name rdr_env dc) -- Make sure to also mark the data constructors as used so that GHC won't -- mistakenly emit -Wunused-imports warnings about them. lift $ addUsedDataCons rdr_env rep_tc unless (not hidden_data_cons) $ bale_out $ derivingHiddenErr tc -- Ensure that a class's associated type variables are suitable for -- GeneralizedNewtypeDeriving or DerivingVia. Unsurprisingly, this check is -- only required for the `newtype` and `via` strategies. -- -- See Note [GND and associated type families] atf_coerce_based_error_checks :: DerivM () atf_coerce_based_error_checks = do cls <- asks denv_cls let bale_out msg = do err <- derivingThingErrMechanism mechanism msg lift $ failWithTc err cls_tyvars = classTyVars cls ats_look_sensible = -- Check (a) from Note [GND and associated type families] no_adfs -- Check (b) from Note [GND and associated type families] && isNothing at_without_last_cls_tv -- Check (d) from Note [GND and associated type families] && isNothing at_last_cls_tv_in_kinds (adf_tcs, atf_tcs) = partition isDataFamilyTyCon at_tcs no_adfs = null adf_tcs -- We cannot newtype-derive data family instances at_without_last_cls_tv = find (\tc -> last_cls_tv `notElem` tyConTyVars tc) atf_tcs at_last_cls_tv_in_kinds = find (\tc -> any (at_last_cls_tv_in_kind . tyVarKind) (tyConTyVars tc) || at_last_cls_tv_in_kind (tyConResKind tc)) atf_tcs at_last_cls_tv_in_kind kind = last_cls_tv `elemVarSet` exactTyCoVarsOfType kind at_tcs = classATs cls last_cls_tv = ASSERT( notNull cls_tyvars ) last cls_tyvars cant_derive_err = vcat [ ppUnless no_adfs adfs_msg , maybe empty at_without_last_cls_tv_msg at_without_last_cls_tv , maybe empty at_last_cls_tv_in_kinds_msg at_last_cls_tv_in_kinds ] adfs_msg = text "the class has associated data types" at_without_last_cls_tv_msg at_tc = hang (text "the associated type" <+> quotes (ppr at_tc) <+> text "is not parameterized over the last type variable") 2 (text "of the class" <+> quotes (ppr cls)) at_last_cls_tv_in_kinds_msg at_tc = hang (text "the associated type" <+> quotes (ppr at_tc) <+> text "contains the last type variable") 2 (text "of the class" <+> quotes (ppr cls) <+> text "in a kind, which is not (yet) allowed") unless ats_look_sensible $ bale_out cant_derive_err doDerivInstErrorChecks2 :: Class -> ClsInst -> ThetaType -> Maybe SrcSpan -> DerivSpecMechanism -> TcM () doDerivInstErrorChecks2 clas clas_inst theta wildcard mechanism = do { traceTc "doDerivInstErrorChecks2" (ppr clas_inst) ; dflags <- getDynFlags ; xpartial_sigs <- xoptM LangExt.PartialTypeSignatures ; wpartial_sigs <- woptM Opt_WarnPartialTypeSignatures -- Error if PartialTypeSignatures isn't enabled when a user tries -- to write @deriving instance _ => Eq (Foo a)@. Or, if that -- extension is enabled, give a warning if -Wpartial-type-signatures -- is enabled. ; case wildcard of Nothing -> pure () Just span -> setSrcSpan span $ do checkTc xpartial_sigs (hang partial_sig_msg 2 pts_suggestion) warnTc (Reason Opt_WarnPartialTypeSignatures) wpartial_sigs partial_sig_msg -- Check for Generic instances that are derived with an exotic -- deriving strategy like DAC -- See Note [Deriving strategies] ; when (exotic_mechanism && className clas `elem` genericClassNames) $ do { failIfTc (safeLanguageOn dflags) gen_inst_err ; when (safeInferOn dflags) (recordUnsafeInfer emptyBag) } } where exotic_mechanism = not $ isDerivSpecStock mechanism partial_sig_msg = text "Found type wildcard" <+> quotes (char '_') <+> text "standing for" <+> quotes (pprTheta theta) pts_suggestion = text "To use the inferred type, enable PartialTypeSignatures" gen_inst_err = text "Generic instances can only be derived in" <+> text "Safe Haskell using the stock strategy." derivingThingFailWith :: Bool -- If True, add a snippet about how not even -- GeneralizedNewtypeDeriving would make this -- declaration work. This only kicks in when -- an explicit deriving strategy is not given. -> SDoc -- The error message -> DerivM a derivingThingFailWith newtype_deriving msg = do err <- derivingThingErrM newtype_deriving msg lift $ failWithTc err genDerivStuff :: DerivSpecMechanism -> SrcSpan -> Class -> [Type] -> [TyVar] -> TcM (LHsBinds GhcPs, BagDerivStuff, [Name]) genDerivStuff mechanism loc clas inst_tys tyvars = case mechanism of -- See Note [Bindings for Generalised Newtype Deriving] DerivSpecNewtype { dsm_newtype_rep_ty = rhs_ty} -> gen_newtype_or_via rhs_ty -- Try a stock deriver DerivSpecStock { dsm_stock_dit = DerivInstTys{dit_rep_tc = rep_tc} , dsm_stock_gen_fn = gen_fn } -> gen_fn loc rep_tc inst_tys -- Try DeriveAnyClass DerivSpecAnyClass -> do let mini_env = mkVarEnv (classTyVars clas `zip` inst_tys) mini_subst = mkTvSubst (mkInScopeSet (mkVarSet tyvars)) mini_env dflags <- getDynFlags tyfam_insts <- -- canDeriveAnyClass should ensure that this code can't be reached -- unless -XDeriveAnyClass is enabled. ASSERT2( isValid (canDeriveAnyClass dflags) , ppr "genDerivStuff: bad derived class" <+> ppr clas ) mapM (tcATDefault loc mini_subst emptyNameSet) (classATItems clas) return ( emptyBag -- No method bindings are needed... , listToBag (map DerivFamInst (concat tyfam_insts)) -- ...but we may need to generate binding for associated type -- family default instances. -- See Note [DeriveAnyClass and default family instances] , [] ) -- Try DerivingVia DerivSpecVia{dsm_via_ty = via_ty} -> gen_newtype_or_via via_ty where gen_newtype_or_via ty = do (binds, faminsts) <- gen_Newtype_binds loc clas tyvars inst_tys ty return (binds, faminsts, []) {- Note [Bindings for Generalised Newtype Deriving] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Consider class Eq a => C a where f :: a -> a newtype N a = MkN [a] deriving( C ) instance Eq (N a) where ... The 'deriving C' clause generates, in effect instance (C [a], Eq a) => C (N a) where f = coerce (f :: [a] -> [a]) This generates a cast for each method, but allows the superclasse to be worked out in the usual way. In this case the superclass (Eq (N a)) will be solved by the explicit Eq (N a) instance. We do *not* create the superclasses by casting the superclass dictionaries for the representation type. See the paper "Safe zero-cost coercions for Haskell". Note [DeriveAnyClass and default family instances] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ When a class has a associated type family with a default instance, e.g.: class C a where type T a type T a = Char then there are a couple of scenarios in which a user would expect T a to default to Char. One is when an instance declaration for C is given without an implementation for T: instance C Int Another scenario in which this can occur is when the -XDeriveAnyClass extension is used: data Example = Example deriving (C, Generic) In the latter case, we must take care to check if C has any associated type families with default instances, because -XDeriveAnyClass will never provide an implementation for them. We "fill in" the default instances using the tcATDefault function from TcClassDcl (which is also used in TcInstDcls to handle the empty instance declaration case). Note [Deriving strategies] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ GHC has a notion of deriving strategies, which allow the user to explicitly request which approach to use when deriving an instance (enabled with the -XDerivingStrategies language extension). For more information, refer to the original issue (#10598) or the associated wiki page: https://gitlab.haskell.org/ghc/ghc/wikis/commentary/compiler/deriving-strategies A deriving strategy can be specified in a deriving clause: newtype Foo = MkFoo Bar deriving newtype C Or in a standalone deriving declaration: deriving anyclass instance C Foo -XDerivingStrategies also allows the use of multiple deriving clauses per data declaration so that a user can derive some instance with one deriving strategy and other instances with another deriving strategy. For example: newtype Baz = Baz Quux deriving (Eq, Ord) deriving stock (Read, Show) deriving newtype (Num, Floating) deriving anyclass C Currently, the deriving strategies are: * stock: Have GHC implement a "standard" instance for a data type, if possible (e.g., Eq, Ord, Generic, Data, Functor, etc.) * anyclass: Use -XDeriveAnyClass * newtype: Use -XGeneralizedNewtypeDeriving * via: Use -XDerivingVia The latter two strategies (newtype and via) are referred to as the "coerce-based" strategies, since they generate code that relies on the `coerce` function. See, for instance, TcDerivInfer.inferConstraintsCoerceBased. The former two strategies (stock and anyclass), in contrast, are referred to as the "originative" strategies, since they create "original" instances instead of "reusing" old instances (by way of `coerce`). See, for instance, TcDerivUtils.checkOriginativeSideConditions. If an explicit deriving strategy is not given, GHC has an algorithm it uses to determine which strategy it will actually use. The algorithm is quite long, so it lives in the Haskell wiki at https://gitlab.haskell.org/ghc/ghc/wikis/commentary/compiler/deriving-strategies ("The deriving strategy resolution algorithm" section). Internally, GHC uses the DerivStrategy datatype to denote a user-requested deriving strategy, and it uses the DerivSpecMechanism datatype to denote what GHC will use to derive the instance after taking the above steps. In other words, GHC will always settle on a DerivSpecMechnism, even if the user did not ask for a particular DerivStrategy (using the algorithm linked to above). Note [Deriving instances for classes themselves] ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Much of the code in TcDeriv assumes that deriving only works on data types. But this assumption doesn't hold true for DeriveAnyClass, since it's perfectly reasonable to do something like this: {-# LANGUAGE DeriveAnyClass #-} class C1 (a :: Constraint) where class C2 where deriving instance C1 C2 -- This is equivalent to `instance C1 C2` If DeriveAnyClass isn't enabled in the code above (i.e., it defaults to stock deriving), we throw a special error message indicating that DeriveAnyClass is the only way to go. We don't bother throwing this error if an explicit 'stock' or 'newtype' keyword is used, since both options have their own perfectly sensible error messages in the case of the above code (as C1 isn't a stock derivable class, and C2 isn't a newtype). ************************************************************************ * * \subsection[TcDeriv-taggery-Names]{What con2tag/tag2con functions are available?} * * ************************************************************************ -} nonUnaryErr :: LHsSigType GhcRn -> SDoc nonUnaryErr ct = quotes (ppr ct) <+> text "is not a unary constraint, as expected by a deriving clause" nonStdErr :: Class -> SDoc nonStdErr cls = quotes (ppr cls) <+> text "is not a stock derivable class (Eq, Show, etc.)" gndNonNewtypeErr :: SDoc gndNonNewtypeErr = text "GeneralizedNewtypeDeriving cannot be used on non-newtypes" derivingNullaryErr :: MsgDoc derivingNullaryErr = text "Cannot derive instances for nullary classes" derivingKindErr :: TyCon -> Class -> [Type] -> Kind -> Bool -> MsgDoc derivingKindErr tc cls cls_tys cls_kind enough_args = sep [ hang (text "Cannot derive well-kinded instance of form" <+> quotes (pprClassPred cls cls_tys <+> parens (ppr tc <+> text "..."))) 2 gen1_suggestion , nest 2 (text "Class" <+> quotes (ppr cls) <+> text "expects an argument of kind" <+> quotes (pprKind cls_kind)) ] where gen1_suggestion | cls `hasKey` gen1ClassKey && enough_args = text "(Perhaps you intended to use PolyKinds)" | otherwise = Outputable.empty derivingViaKindErr :: Class -> Kind -> Type -> Kind -> MsgDoc derivingViaKindErr cls cls_kind via_ty via_kind = hang (text "Cannot derive instance via" <+> quotes (pprType via_ty)) 2 (text "Class" <+> quotes (ppr cls) <+> text "expects an argument of kind" <+> quotes (pprKind cls_kind) <> char ',' $+$ text "but" <+> quotes (pprType via_ty) <+> text "has kind" <+> quotes (pprKind via_kind)) derivingEtaErr :: Class -> [Type] -> Type -> MsgDoc derivingEtaErr cls cls_tys inst_ty = sep [text "Cannot eta-reduce to an instance of form", nest 2 (text "instance (...) =>" <+> pprClassPred cls (cls_tys ++ [inst_ty]))] derivingThingErr :: Bool -> Class -> [Type] -> Maybe (DerivStrategy GhcTc) -> MsgDoc -> MsgDoc derivingThingErr newtype_deriving cls cls_args mb_strat why = derivingThingErr' newtype_deriving cls cls_args mb_strat (maybe empty derivStrategyName mb_strat) why derivingThingErrM :: Bool -> MsgDoc -> DerivM MsgDoc derivingThingErrM newtype_deriving why = do DerivEnv { denv_cls = cls , denv_inst_tys = cls_args , denv_strat = mb_strat } <- ask pure $ derivingThingErr newtype_deriving cls cls_args mb_strat why derivingThingErrMechanism :: DerivSpecMechanism -> MsgDoc -> DerivM MsgDoc derivingThingErrMechanism mechanism why = do DerivEnv { denv_cls = cls , denv_inst_tys = cls_args , denv_strat = mb_strat } <- ask pure $ derivingThingErr' (isDerivSpecNewtype mechanism) cls cls_args mb_strat (derivStrategyName $ derivSpecMechanismToStrategy mechanism) why derivingThingErr' :: Bool -> Class -> [Type] -> Maybe (DerivStrategy GhcTc) -> MsgDoc -> MsgDoc -> MsgDoc derivingThingErr' newtype_deriving cls cls_args mb_strat strat_msg why = sep [(hang (text "Can't make a derived instance of") 2 (quotes (ppr pred) <+> via_mechanism) $$ nest 2 extra) <> colon, nest 2 why] where strat_used = isJust mb_strat extra | not strat_used, newtype_deriving = text "(even with cunning GeneralizedNewtypeDeriving)" | otherwise = empty pred = mkClassPred cls cls_args via_mechanism | strat_used = text "with the" <+> strat_msg <+> text "strategy" | otherwise = empty derivingHiddenErr :: TyCon -> SDoc derivingHiddenErr tc = hang (text "The data constructors of" <+> quotes (ppr tc) <+> ptext (sLit "are not all in scope")) 2 (text "so you cannot derive an instance for it") standaloneCtxt :: LHsSigWcType GhcRn -> SDoc standaloneCtxt ty = hang (text "In the stand-alone deriving instance for") 2 (quotes (ppr ty))