6.4.18. Impredicative polymorphism

ImpredicativeTypes
Implies:RankNTypes
Since:9.2.1 (unreliable in 6.10 - 9.0)

Allow impredicative polymorphic types.

In general, GHC will only instantiate a polymorphic function at a monomorphic type (one with no foralls). For example,

runST :: (forall s. ST s a) -> a
id :: forall b. b -> b

foo = id runST   -- Rejected

The definition of foo is rejected because one would have to instantiate id’s type with b := (forall s. ST s a) -> a, and that is not allowed. Instantiating polymorphic type variables with polymorphic types is called impredicative polymorphism.

GHC has robust support for impredicative polymorphism, enabled with ImpredicativeTypes, using the so-called Quick Look inference algorithm. It is described in the paper A quick look at impredicativity (Serrano et al, ICFP 2020).

Switching on ImpredicativeTypes

  • Switches on RankNTypes
  • Allows user-written types to have foralls under type constructors, not just under arrows. For example f :: Maybe (forall a. [a] -> [a]) is a legal type signature.
  • Allows polymorphic types in Visible Type Application (when TypeApplications is enabled). For example, you can write reverse @(forall b. b->b) xs. Using VTA with a polymorphic type argument is useful in cases when Quick Look cannot infer the correct instantiation.
  • Switches on the Quick Look type inference algorithm, as described in the paper. This allows the compiler to infer impredicative instantiations of polymorphic functions in many cases. For example, reverse xs will typecheck even if xs :: [forall a. a->a], by instantiating reverse at type forall a. a->a.

Note that the treatment of type-class constraints and implicit parameters remains entirely monomorphic, even with ImpredicativeTypes. Specifically:

  • You cannot apply a type class to a polymorphic type. This is illegal: f :: C (forall a. a->a) => [a] -> [a]
  • You cannot give an instance declaration with a polymorphic argument. This is illegal: instance C (forall a. a->a)
  • An implicit parameter cannot have a polymorphic type: g :: (?x :: forall a. a->a) => [a] -> [a]

For many years GHC has a special case for the function ($), that allows it to typecheck an application like runST $ (do { ... }), even though that instantiation may be impredicative. This special case remains: even without ImpredicativeTypes GHC switches on Quick Look for applications of ($).

This flag was available in earlier versions of GHC (6.10.1 - 9.0), but the behavior was unpredictable and not officially supported.